Socialism vs. Capitalism: What’s the Difference?

Socialism is an economic system characterized by public ownership of the means of production directed by a central planning group (usually the government through state control) on behalf of citizens. Different forms of socialism exist, from countries that offer social services to the disadvantaged to pure socialist economies defined by complete government control of the business and labor market. Socialist states aim to provide an egalitarian society through equal opportunity and distribution of public goods, providing basic human needs such as employment, universal health care, housing, food, and clothing.

Capitalist systems depend on private ownership of the means of production, with the goal of economic growth based on a free market economy of supply and demand. In capitalist societies, private individuals own and control the business and labor market, operating with few or no government controls. Though capitalism may quickly fuel economic development, the purest form of capitalism (also called laissez-faire capitalism) provides no safety nets or social protections against income inequality.

The capitalism vs. socialism argument debates whether state ownership in a socialist society outweighs the potential economic advantages of a capitalist economy. In the modern world, economic theorists believe the truth lies somewhere in the middle, with many countries embracing aspects of both through democratic socialism. The differences between the two purest forms of each system include:

1. 1. Business control: In a capitalist society, the economy depends on private enterprise, where the means of production falls to individual privately owned companies and industries. Under socialism, the public owns all the means of production and all natural resources, and a central planning authority regulates businesses on their behalf.
2. 2. Consumer choice: Because socialist governments provide products and services to their citizens, they have no market incentive to provide a wide variety of products. Capitalist economies thrive on market forces, which means different businesses compete against one another, and consumers theoretically benefit from many choices for the same product.
3. 3. Consumer prices: The government determines the price of goods and services in a socialist country. In a capitalist society, market forces of supply and demand set prices, which means you may have to pay a higher price for a product during an economic downturn.
4. 4. Efficiency and innovation: In a capitalist system, businesses must be efficient and innovative to compete in the free market. Without competition, the central planning authority of a socialist society has no financial motivation to avoid inefficiencies or innovate.
5. 5. Income equality: In capitalism, market forces determine how well an individual does financially, and economic inequality persists. Socialist systems rely on the redistribution of wealth, promoting a classless society where no individual earns much more than another.
6. 6. Property rights: Anyone living within a capitalist system may own private property. Socialist systems may allow citizens to own personal property, but only as a consumer good.
7. 7. Provision of basic needs: In a socialist system, the government meets basic needs, such as housing, health care, and food. In a capitalist system, individuals must earn enough money to supply these items independently.
8. 8. Taxation: Socialist societies depend on high taxes to supply citizens with public services. In purely capitalist economies, the privatization of businesses means individuals don’t have to pay as much into the system to support the collective.

Economists define most capitalist countries as mixed economies, with capitalism as an economic structure supported by some social welfare programs. Examples of capitalism include:

1. 1. Ireland: Some of the largest technology companies in the world have established operations in Ireland due to its low corporate tax rates and free market economy. Its capitalist approach allows this relatively small country to play an important role in the global market.
2. 2. Luxembourg: Ranked fifth on the Economic Freedom rankings, Luxembourg enjoys a robust capitalist economy of manufacturing and financial services. Its stable government and excellent electrical grid make it an important global hub for information technology.
3. 3. New Zealand: New Zealand’s capitalist economy uses open trade and low tariffs on imports and exports to lure private business ventures. New Zealand successfully sends agricultural products to China, Australia, and the US.
4. 4. Switzerland: Switzerland’s low corporate tax rate and free market economy make it an inviting country for entrepreneurship. It boasts a very successful financial services sector and prides itself on its precision manufacturing.
5. 5. United States of America: The US identifies as a capitalist society because of its free market economy, but federal programs like Social Security and Medicare give it some socialist tendencies.

Throughout world history, socialist countries have come and gone, some slipping into Marxist-Leninist communist regimes. Like capitalism, countries that consider themselves socialist usually possess some capitalist overtones. Examples of socialism include:

1. 1. Cuba: Though Cuba embraced a Marxist-Leninist socialist economy under Fidel Castro, in recent years, its citizens voted to maintain socialism politically but instituted new economic policies, including rights to private property and some free market activity.
2. 2. North Korea: A completely closed Marxist-Leninist communist party economy, North Korea governs its people through a strict dictatorship.
3. 3. The People’s Republic of China: China’s Marxist-Leninist communist government controls many of the country’s means of production but allows private companies to profit within specific economic regions such as Shanghai.
4. 4. The Soviet Union: The former Soviet Union (also known as the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics or USSR) called itself a socialist country under Marxist-Leninist terminology before its collapse in 1991.
5. 5. Venezuela: Venezuela’s adoption of a socialist government in 2010 hurt the country’s economy due to poor central planning, government self-interest, and corruption. In the last several years, the government has started adopting capitalist economic activity again by allowing private ownership of for-profit companies.

Get the MasterClass Annual Membership for exclusive access to video lessons taught by the world’s best, including Paul Krugman, Doris Kearns Goodwin, Ron Finley, Jane Goodall, and more.