Pecan Pie: Origins, Variations, and Easy Pecan Pie Recipe

Pecan pie is a quintessential American dessert featuring a mosaic of pecan halves suspended in a silky, sugary blend of eggs, butter and a sweetener—traditionally corn syrup—held together in a flaky pie crust.

It may feel as though pecan pie’s always been found between the pumpkin pie and apple pie—the holy trinity of the American holiday dessert table—but as with any iconic dish, there are a few urban legends and tangled histories around how it got there.

The makers of Karo syrup claim to have invented the pie in the 1930s as a revolutionary new way to use their corn syrup, but evidence of pecan pie actually predates the invention of corn syrup: classical versions used molasses or cane syrups.

Pecans are native to the southern United States—the nuts were prominent in the diets of Native Americans living in the area more than 8,000 years ago—and some theories have posited that French settlers in Louisiana, after being introduced to pecans by these local tribes, conceived of the dessert.

The earliest instance of a pecan pie recipe as it’s known today was in 1886, in an issue of Harper’s Bazaar.

Here are four variations of the classic that go down just as well.

1. 1. Maple. Swap in maple syrup for the corn syrup in any recipe for a toffee-infused sweetness and soft, crystallized texture.
2. 2. Bourbon or whiskey. For a pecan pie with all the smooth fire of an adult beverage, add a few tablespoons of either bourbon or whiskey to the butter and sugar mixture. The alcohol will burn off, and leave behind a warm, tangy, bite.
3. 3. Chocolate. Chocolate chips or cocoa butter give the innate sweetness of pecan pie a grounded earthy note with just enough bitterness, depending on the kind of chocolate you use. Incorporate cocoa butter into the filling and adjust the sugar levels accordingly.
4. 4. Handheld. Swap out a regular pie crust for a shortbread crust and bake pecan pie bars in a square pan.