Essential Guide to Minimalist and Maximalist Writing Styles

A minimalist writing style refers to writing with a small, specific focus, usually devoid of flowery, excessively descriptive language and backstory. Literary minimalism prioritizes brevity, allowing the reader to make up for a lack of verbiage with their imagination. Minimalism is sometimes seen as a rejection or rebellion against postmodernism, focusing on slices of life and general context rather than relying on literary conventions.

A maximalist writing style is broad and complex, involving many different literary devices and elements. Maximalism came to prominence in contemporary American novels in the 1970s, only gaining popularity in Europe by the twenty-first century. Maximalism is often seen in postmodern books, which are usually more digressive and generous with its metaphors, descriptions, and other figurative language, covering a more comprehensive range of subject matter and emotional exploration.

Purveyors of literary theory like Nick Levey (author of the 2016 book Maximalism in Contemporary American Literature: The Uses of Detail), Stefano Ercolino (author of the 2014 book The Maximalist Novel: From Thomas Pynchon's Gravity's Rainbow to Roberto Bolaño's 2666), and others like Franco Moretti and Tom LeClair, all offer conflicting definitions on the true embodiment of maximalist style.

There are some key differences between the minimalist and the maximalist novel or story.

Some well-known writers of minimalist fiction include:

1. 1. Frederick Barthelme: Barthelme was also a minimalist author widely known for his use of “K-Mart” realism—a term used to describe narratives in American literary minimalism centered around the bleak nature of the ordinary, working-class, or “blue-collar” experience) to explore the more mundane aspects of existence. His novel Natural Selection (1990) explores the defeated nature and cynicism of its main male protagonist and how he deals with the malaise of everyday life.
2. 2. Ann Beattie: American short story and novel writer Ann Beattie is known for her flat sentences and matter-of-fact tone, delivering a terse narrative through economical use of words, particularly noticeable in her 1980 novel Falling in Place.
3. 3. Samuel Beckett: In the play Waiting for Godot (1953), Beckett creates an entire existential narrative featuring two characters who contemplate their day as they wait for the ambiguous Godot to appear. However, he never arrives, and his identity is not revealed.
   
4. 4. Raymond Carver: Carver was a short story writer who helped introduce minimalist literature into American fiction during the 1970s. “A Small, Good Thing” is one of Carver’s minimalistic stories that uses short, compact sentences to emphasize and perpetuate the narrative’s seriousness and sadness. What We Talk About When We Talk About Love (1981) is a collection of Carver’s short stories that uses economic language and brief prose.
5. 5. Ernest Hemingway: The Old Man and the Sea (1952) is considered a prime example of “barebones storytelling,” with Hemingway using simple, direct language to portray this brief but emotional narrative to the reader in this minimalist short story. Additionally, In Our Time (1925) is a short story collection by Hemingway that exemplifies the minimalist style. A prolific piece of flash fiction often misattributed to Hemingway is the six-word story: “For sale. Baby shoes. Never worn,” which creates a world of imagination and interpretation using as few words as possible.
6. 6. Amy Hempel: Hempel is known as a master of minimalist writing. Sing to It (2019) is a collection of short stories containing works around a page long. This aggregation of short vignettes makes use of sparse prose to create a powerful, emotional impact.
7. 7. Cormac McCarthy: McCarthy’s The Road (2006) features two characters: a father and son, who navigate a post-apocalyptic landscape together, with only dialogue and behavior to indicate their identities. McCarthy does not employ extensive backstory or endless description to these characters, allowing only their actions to define who they are for the reader.
8. 8. Mary Robison: Robison’s 2001 novel Why Did I Ever uses fragmented paragraphs to create a narrative, stringing together minimal words to express the main character’s unhappiness along with a manifestation of her attention-deficit disorder (ADD).

Some authors who exemplify the maximalist style include:

1. 1. Don DeLillo: Following an advertising executive in New York during the Nixon era, Underworld (1997) explores the rise of global capitalism, the decline of American manufacturing, the CIA, and civil rights, among other themes, through nihilism and the fantastical appearances of American mythos figures.
2. 2. Thomas Pynchon: Thomas Pynchon’s Gravity’s Rainbow (1973) is an example of maximalist literature, using complex structure to cover various subjects such as culture, science, and literary propriety. Some early critics viewed this work as overwritten and obscene, though some now claim it to be one of the greatest American novels ever written.
3. 3. Zadie Smith: Smith’s White Teeth (2000) is a maximalist exploration of different historical, cultural, and social classes. The characters in the novel also come from different religious backgrounds, offering a complex, blended narrative laid across 20 fragmented chapters.
4. 4. David Foster Wallace: Wallace’s Infinite Jest (1996) embodies maximalism through his postmodern characters, overuse of endnotes, and meandering consciousness.

Become a better writer with the MasterClass Annual Membership. Gain access to exclusive video lessons taught by the world’s best, including Salman Rushdie, Neil Gaiman, Walter Mosley, Margaret Atwood, Joyce Carol Oates, Dan Brown, and more.