Leather vs. Fabric Sofas: Pros and Cons of Each Sofa Type

A leather sofa is a piece of furniture with space for several people to sit simultaneously. It is a bench seat with leather upholstery, two arms and seat cushions, and a range of seating options, from loveseats that seat two people to sectional sofas that offer multiple independent seats, which you can arrange in different combinations or positions. Leather sofas may also double as sleeper sofas, which convert into a bed.

It’s important to note that a leather sofa is different from a leather couch. The two terms seem interchangeable, but a couch is typically smaller than a sofa and closer in size to a chaise lounge. A leather couch has a straight arm design or no arms at all and is rarely a sleeper.

A fabric sofa is a piece of furniture that can seat multiple people simultaneously. Furniture makers use several different types of fabrics for sofa material, including natural fibers made from wool, linen, cotton, or silk. They may also use synthetic fibers made from petroleum or polypropylene to make upholstery fabric. Blending synthetic fibers such as polyester, nylon, acrylic, and olefin with natural fibers gives fabric sofas greater durability.

Leather fans on a budget may opt for microfiber fabric, which features tightly woven synthetic fibers that mimic the feeling of leather.

There are several advantages to adding leather sofas to your home décor, including:

1. 1. Appearance: When it comes to appearance, leather sofas are more sleek and elegant than fabric sofas. Among the most prized leather sofas is the classic Chesterfield, which features rolled arms the same height as the back of the couch. This range of looks makes them more than just bachelor pad or living room furniture; leather couches suit many rooms, with modern and mid-century interior design styles.
2. 2. Hypoallergenic: Leather sofas are the perfect sofa for allergy sufferers. Leather is hypoallergenic and repels dust mites, pet dander, pet hair, and other allergens, which collect in fabric sofas.
3. 3. Stain-resistant: Leather sofas are highly durable due to the tanning process used in their manufacture. As a result, they repel most food and beverage spills. They only need occasional light cleaning with a damp cloth and can last for decades with proper care. Learn how to clean leather properly with this complete guide.

There are several advantages to owning fabric sofas, including:

1. 1. Wide selections: Fabric sofas come in a vast array of patterns, colors, materials, and textures, making it easy to match the seating to your home décor.
2. 2. Comfortable: Fabric sofas are soft, pliable, and comfortable. However, the type of fabric used for the sofa often determines the comfort level. High-quality fabric is soft but not loose and won’t wrinkle when you stand up.
3. 3. Budget-friendly: Fabric sofas are typically cost-effective because of their wide availability and popularity. Certain types of high-end fabrics may be more expensive than others, but the total cost of the sofa will be lower than the same model with leather upholstery.

While stain-resistant and hypoallergenic, leather sofas also have several disadvantages, including:

1. 1. Visible scratches: While durable, leather can take a beating from young children and animals. Scratches and other marks are far more visible on leather than fabric upholstery.
2. 2. Heat retention and firmness: Leather sofas can be less comfortable and more firm than fabric sofas. They also retain more heat in the summer months and cold in the fall and winter than fabric furniture.
3. 3. Expensive: Leather sofas often cost more than fabric sofas. Certain types of leather are less costly than others, but you may sacrifice durability when pursuing pieces at a lower price range.

There are some disadvantages to owning a fabric sofa, including:

1. 1. Can harbor allergens: The fabrics used for sofas are breathable, meaning there are tiny spaces for dust, dust mites, mold, and pet dander to gather and accumulate.
2. 2. Requires special cleaning: Some manufacturers treat fabric sofas with stain-resistant chemicals, but they still stain more than leather couches, and deep-set stains can be permanent. Good quality fabric will stand up to more stains but may still require special cleaning. Fabric sofas also require regular vacuuming to remove surface dirt and dust.
3. 3. Material can wear down over time: Regular use can cause pilling on the sofa material and even cause it to wear thin over time, but high-quality fabrics may last longer. If you’re considering a fabric sofa, ask about its rub rate; this refers to the Martindale rub test, which determines a sofa’s durability. A rub rate of more than 25,000 is optimal.

Furniture manufacturers use many different types of leather to make leather sofas, and retailers determine the price range for new sofas based on the leather style.

1. 1. Full-grain: Full-grain leather retains its original texture and is also genuine leather, meaning that it’s 100 percent animal hide and uses no additional products.
2. 2. Top grain: Top-grain leather is a polished full-grain leather without any visible imperfections. Top-grain leather is the thickest and most durable type of leather because it includes the outside layer of the hide, referred to as “the grain.”
3. 3. Bi-cast: Manufacturers add a layer of vinyl to bi-cast leather, giving it the appearance of full-grain leather but making it stiffer and decreasing its quality.
4. 4. Suede: Suede comes from the underside of the animal skin, which has a soft, smooth nap and is usually made from younger animals, as older animals’ skin tends to be rougher.
5. 5. Aniline: Manufacturers use a dye treatment to create aniline leather. Full aniline leather has a translucent dye, while semi-aniline’s pigmented. Faux leather uses plastics and rubber but retains the feel of real leather.

Master everything from color theory to pattern mixing with the MasterClass Annual Membership and exclusive lessons from award-winning interior designers like Corey Damen Jenkins and Kelly Wearstler. From shopping for statement furniture to designing a lighting scheme to choosing the newest member of your plant family, the skills you’ll pick up are sure to make your house, apartment, or condo feel even more like a home.