Dutch Auction Pros and Cons: How a Dutch Auction Works

A Dutch auction is a type of descending-price auction in which the auctioneer begins at a very high offering price, incrementally reducing the price until a buyer places a bid and wins the item. In this format, the first bidder wins the item; this avoids a bidding war that would potentially slow down the auction process, making Dutch auctions a reliable and quick approach for items that need fast sales, like fresh flowers and produce.

A Dutch auction is in contrast to a traditional ascending-price auction, in which the auctioneer begins at a lower price, bidders place bids, and the price range gradually increases until all but one of the bidders drop out. The term Dutch auction might take its name from the format’s popularity in Holland, where growers use the model to sell flowers in bulk.

A Dutch auction works in a simple format:

• The auctioneer shows the item. Before a Dutch auction begins, the auctioneer will show the item and offer any details or information the potential buyers need before they agree to bid.
• Bidders silently consider their highest bid. In the period of time before the auction officially starts, bidders will consider their capital and how much they would be willing to spend on the item.
• The auctioneer introduces the highest price. The auction begins when the auctioneer names the first price. This maximum price should be so high the seller does not believe the item will sell.
• The auctioneer lowers the price incrementally. When no one accepts the item at the highest price, the auctioneer lowers the price by a set amount. For example, if the starting price is $2,000, the auctioneer might offer the next price at $1,900.
• A bidder bids. Once the price reaches a range one of the bidders feels comfortable paying, the bidder will bid on the item. This immediately ends the auction, and the item goes to the first bidder.

A Dutch auction format favors the sellers slightly more, although it has advantages for both sellers and buyers. Consider these three points:

1. 1. A Dutch auction is faster than a traditional auction: Since a Dutch auction avoids the potential for a bidding war (and even forgoes the possibility of multiple bids), it is a faster auction process, ideal for items with short shelf lives, like flowers, tobacco, and fresh food items.
2. 2. A Dutch auction can fetch better prices for sellers. In a Dutch auction, bidders experience greater uncertainty since they don’t know what prices the other bidders are willing to pay. This uncertainty can make them more willing to pay a higher price to make a successful bid and quickly achieve closure.
3. 3. A Dutch auction can help determine the best asking price. A Dutch auction can be a useful tool in price discovery since sellers can determine the highest price that bidders are willing to pay, independent of bidding wars and other pressure. For this reason, some companies have used Dutch auctions to determine their initial public offerings.

While popular in format, a Dutch auction has disadvantages for both buyers and sellers. Here are a few downsides:

1. 1. A Dutch auction can be emotionally taxing for participants. Since a Dutch auction includes a high level of uncertainty for the participants, it can be a higher-stress environment than a traditional auction and cause bidders to act out of fear or stress. Bidders in Dutch auctions more often display winner regret (in which the winner believes they overpaid) and loser regret (in which the losing participants believe they underbid).
2. 2. A Dutch auction is not ideal for slow-paced items. The Dutch auction process is particularly suited to items that need to sell quickly—like flowers and produce—since the first bid is the winning bid and items can’t become tangled up in a bidding war. For items that don’t require this kind of rapid sale, however, such as cars or tech items, the format might preclude valuable bidding that could fetch a better price for sellers.
3. 3. A Dutch auction might drive prices up for buyers. With a heavy emphasis on uncertainty, a Dutch auction can encourage bidders to bid early and high to get a sense of closure and end the stress of the auction. While this high bid price is an advantage for the sellers, it is a disadvantage for the buyers, who want to purchase items at the lowest price possible.

Some companies have used Dutch auctions to determine their initial public offerings. In traditional IPO pricing, underwriters like investment banks have the power to offer a number of shares to institutional investors at a discounted or reserve price, hedging out smaller investors.

Using a Dutch auction IPO can democratize the IPO process by taking the power of allocation and pricing away from underwriters and allowing small investors to participate; however, the democratization process can also result in unexpected influence on the opening price since smaller investors might bid without doing significant research.

Get the MasterClass Annual Membership for exclusive access to video lessons taught by business luminaries, including Howard Schultz, Chris Voss, Robin Roberts, Sara Blakely, Daniel Pink, Bob Iger, Anna Wintour, and more.