Collectivist Culture: Pros and Cons of a Collectivist Culture

In cross-cultural psychology, a collectivist culture is a community that prioritizes the group over the individual. Collectivistic cultures emphasize personality traits and attributes like cohesion, harmony, duty, interdependence, achievement of group goals, and conflict avoidance. Many Asian cultures tend to be collectivist, including those in China, South Korea, and Japan.

The principle of collective culture came from Dutch social scientist Geert Hofstede and his research on cultural dimensions. Other notable researchers in the field include Shinobu Kitayama and Hazel Rose Markus.

The opposite of a collectivist culture is an individualistic culture, which prioritizes the individual over the collective group. Individualistic cultures emphasize attributes like uniqueness, self-esteem, independence, and privacy. Many Western cultures tend to be individualist; examples of individualist countries include the United States and the United Kingdom.

Collectivism has several advantages, including:

• Higher unity and harmony: Since those in collectivist societies value the group dynamic, there is a much higher sense of togetherness and community.
• Increased feeling of support: Those in collectivist societies tend to feel as if they have a stronger network of friends, close family members, and extended family who will support them during times of difficulty.
• Stronger sense of empathy: Members in collectivist societies tend to spend more of their time and energy thinking about others rather than themselves, resulting in a culture with a much stronger sense of empathy and consideration for others.

Collectivism can come with several disadvantages, including:

• Less celebration of diversity: Since collectivist countries prioritize the group, they focus less on individual uniqueness or diversity, and collectivism often celebrates homogeneity, similarity, and adherence to cultural norms rather than differences in personality or cultural background.
• Less encouragement of self-expression: Collectivism emphasizes the will of the group over the individual, which means self-expression isn’t strongly encouraged and many group members may stay silent to allow better decision-making for the whole community.
• Less focus on personal development: In collectivist communities, members spend less time thinking about themselves, resulting in less emphasis on personal development or individual goals.

The individualism-collectivism divide in social psychology outlines two different cultures of community that diverge in the following areas:

• Basic emphasis: At their core, collectivist and individualist cultures are two opposite community models with opposing emphases and strong cultural differences. Collective cultures emphasize the well-being of the group over the individual, while individualistic cultures focus on the well-being of the individual over the group.
• Cognition: According to research in the social sciences, those in collectivist cultures tend to take a more holistic approach to cognition, while those in individualistic cultures tend to emphasize analytical thinking over all other cognitive abilities.
• Emotional display: Those in collectivist cultures can encourage hiding emotion and avoiding conflict, while those in individualistic cultures tend to be comfortable displaying emotion and discussing conflict.
• Unity and harmony: Collectivist societies tend to be more unified and harmonious than individualist societies.
• Values: Collectivism emphasizes values geared toward the in-group—like cohesion, interdependence, and conflict avoidance—while individualistic cultures emphasize cultural values geared toward individual rights, like uniqueness, self-expression, and privacy.

Practicing empathy can help you lead more effectively while building stronger relationships across the personal and professional facets of your life. Challenge your perceptions with the MasterClass Annual Membership and take lessons on emotional intelligence from Pharrell Williams, Roxane Gay, Gloria Steinem, Dr. Cornel West, Walter Mosley, Robert Reffkin, and Robin Arzón.