Charcoal vs. Gas Grill: How Do They Compare?

A charcoal grill is a type of home grill that uses lump charcoal or charcoal briquettes as a heating source to cook food. The charcoal fuel is typically located under the grill grates, with wood chips and lighter fluid starting up the hot coals. Charcoal grills come in all different shapes, including pellet grills, kettle grills, and chimney starters.

Charcoal is popular among BBQ enthusiasts because many people consider this method a more authentic form of grilling. This is due to the fact that char-grilling gives food an unmistakable smoky flavor. However, charcoal grilling can be less efficient than gas grilling and also tends to result in a less even cook.

A gas grill is a type of grill that cooks food with gas jets located under its cooking surface. Gas grills are often made out of stainless steel and designed in a cart style that is large, expensive, and rarely portable. These grills are typically fueled by either natural gas or liquid propane. Natural gas grills require you to cook up your grill to your home's gas line, meaning you won't be able to easily move your grill around. Adding a propane tank makes it a portable grill. However, natural gas burns cleaner and is more affordable than propane.

When you’re choosing which type of grill is right for you, it’s important to have a sense of which one suits your needs and cooking setup best. Here is a list of the main differences between charcoal and gas grilling.

• Cooking temperatures: Charcoal grills are typically capable of wider temperature ranges and can reach temperatures up to 1200 degrees Fahrenheit. Most propane gas grills only reach 600 degrees Fahrenheit. There are gas grills that are capable of reaching very high temperatures but these are typically more expensive than regular gas grills. However, temperature control is much easier using a propane grill.
• Flavors: A charcoal grill will give your food a smoky flavor, while a gas grill will cook your food with a cleaner flavor. If you want the smoke flavor of a charcoal grill with a gas grill, you can invest in a smoke box to infuse your food with a smoky taste.
• Price: A charcoal grill is typically more affordable than a gas grill. Depending on the style, charcoal grills can cost as low as $30. On the other hand, the fuel cost of heating a charcoal grill can end up being more expensive than heating a propane gas grill. It’s easy to burn through charcoal fuel far quicker than you would use up the contents of a propane tank.
• Heat-up time: A gas grill heats up much faster than a charcoal grill, which needs time for the coals to build up heat. Gas grills are the better option for people who want to grill food quickly.
• Heat distribution: Gas grills can be more versatile because you have greater control of how heat is distributed over the different parts of the cooking grate. It is more difficult to control the heat levels in a charcoal grill than in a gas grill.
• Environmental impact: Gas grills are more environmentally friendly than charcoal grills, which produce lots of waste in the charcoal ash as well as fumes.

Become a better chef with the MasterClass Annual Membership. Gain access to exclusive video lessons taught by the world’s best, including Aaron Franklin, Yotam Ottolenghi, Gabriela Cámara, Niki Nakayama, Chef Thomas Keller, Dominique Ansel, Gordon Ramsay, Alice Waters, and more.