Ceteris Paribus Explained: 5 Economic Uses for Ceteris Paribus

The Latin phrase “ceteris paribus” translates to “all else being equal.” The ceteris paribus laws consider how one economic variable affects another variable when all other variables remain the same. Ceteris paribus, first covered in English economist Alfred Marshall’s The Principles of Economic Analysis, creates rules and systems to bypass human nature or areas of limited knowledge by applying a scientific methodology.

Ceteris paribus and mutatis mutandis are two economics laws that study the cause-and-effect relationship between multiple, specific variables. The difference between these laws include:

• Number of variables: “Mutatis mutandis” is a Latin phrase meaning “the necessary changes having been made.” This considers how all variables interact with one another, whereas ceteris paribus studies an independent variable and a dependent variable.
• Cause and effect: The purpose of mutatis mutandis is to understand the relationships between variables and how multiple variables change, whereas ceteris paribus focuses on understanding causation.
  
• Real-world models: Because mutatis mutandis analyzes several variables and their effects on one another, the analysis is more complex and accurate in real-world predictions.
• Application: Mutatis mutandis is more often used in law than economics to compare two or more cases or contracts. Economists use ceteris paribus to build and test models to analyze supply and demand, the gross domestic product, and interest rates.

The methodology of ceteris paribus is helpful to economists studying the following:

1. 1. Supply chain: Ceteris paribus considers production factors, such as logistics, sourcing, competition, and trends with buyers to determine the price of goods. For example, a bread seller observes the costs of the ingredients, labor, packaging, and distribution, in addition to competitors, economic inflation, and consumer trends. Ceteris paribus stipulates that if other factors remain the same, a decrease in the supply of bread will cause prices to rise.
2. 2. The law of supply and demand: In the law of demand, buyers demand less of an economic good when prices are higher. The law of supply says that sellers will supply more of an economic good when prices are higher. The interaction of these two laws determines the actual market price and volume of goods. Ceteris paribus identifies, isolates, and tests the impact of an independent variable that would affect these two laws and the causal factors in the market supply and prices.
3. 3. Gross domestic product: Economists use ceteris paribus to study the GDP, assuming that variables remain fixed to determine the effect in the money market.
4. 4. Interest rates: If the interest rates increase, the independent variable, then the demand for debt goes down as the cost of borrowing increases, the dependent variable.
5. 5. Minimum wage: Economists use ceteris paribus to determine the potential effects of a minimum wage increase, including the possible outcome of fewer jobs available if companies must pay employees more.

Ceteris paribus is essential in economics as it brings a fact-focused analysis to the social science. Some advantages include:

1. 1. Scientific method: Ceteris paribus stipulates that all variables are controlled, applying a scientific method to the social science of economics.
2. 2. Positive economics: Contrary to normative economics that focuses on value judgments, positive economics can test theories using ceteris paribus to make predictions that will hopefully be accurate in the real world.
3. 3. Macroeconomics and microeconomics: Nearly all mainstream macroeconomic and microeconomic models use ceteris paribus, making it an essential tool for those studying this social science.
4. 4. Price discovery: Ceteris paribus allows economists to create static supply and demand charts and a pricing framework. This framework shows a demand curve in which ceteris paribus conditions remain constant.

There are some disadvantages to using the ceteris paribus law, mainly because it requires assumptions. Some drawbacks to this law include:

1. 1. Human nature: Ceteris paribus assumptions ignore the human impact on economic trends, and therefore, an essential market aspect.
   
2. 2. Pricing: Ceteris paribus assists in price-discovery at the beginning stages of production; however, real-life prices are ultimately dictated by subjective value versus the price consumers will pay, making this early step relatively unnecessary.
3. 3. Variables: Ceteris paribus focuses on one variable and its effect; however, in economics, there are many variables to consider, making it a challenge to cover all possible independent variables.

Get the MasterClass Annual Membership for exclusive access to video lessons taught by the world’s best, including Paul Krugman, Doris Kearns Goodwin, Ron Finley, Jane Goodall, and more.