Can Dogs Eat Pumpkin Pie? 4 Risks of Pumpkin Pie for Dogs

No, dogs cannot eat pumpkin pie due to the toxicity of seasonings like nutmeg and the amount of sugar and fat. Feeding your dog a slice of pumpkin pie or canned pumpkin pie filling can lead to stomach upset, especially for small dogs.

Ingestion of other pumpkin-flavored baked treats like pumpkin bread is not safe either, as these also contain sugar, fat, and toxic ingredients like nutmeg or the artificial sweetener xylitol.

Dog owners should not feed their pets pumpkin pie. Pumpkin pie contains:

1. 1. Fats and oils: Pumpkin pie filling and the pie crust contain saturated fats and oils that can disrupt your dog’s digestive system, leading to an upset stomach or abdominal pain. Too much fat in your dog’s diet can also lead to serious issues like pancreatitis. Whipped cream, a popular topping for pumpkin pie, is also full of fat.
2. 2. High quantities of sugar: The high sugar content in pumpkin pie makes it unhealthy for dogs. Too much sugar can lead to weight gain and obesity. It can also result in spikes in blood sugar levels and an elevated heart rate. Sugar-free pumpkin pie recipes may call for the artificial sweetener xylitol, which is toxic to dog breeds.
3. 3. Toxic seasonings: Pumpkin pie spice contains allspice and nutmeg. Allspice contains eugenols, which can harm your dog’s liver, and nutmeg contains myristicin, which can lead to high blood pressure, disorientation, or seizures.

While pumpkin pie and canned pumpkin pie filling are not safe for dogs because of the sugar, seasonings, and dairy ingredients, dogs can eat plain pumpkin purée in limited quantities. You can find unseasoned canned pumpkin purée at the grocery store, or you can purchase a whole pumpkin at your local farmers’ market and make a homemade purée. Cooked pumpkin is safer for dogs than raw pumpkin, so roast or steam the fresh pumpkin.

Plain pumpkin can offer your pet health benefits; pumpkin is full of nutrients and antioxidants, like vitamin A and potassium, and it can treat issues like constipation. However, avoid feeding your dog large amounts of pumpkin because the high fiber content can lead to diarrhea.

Certain human foods can cause adverse reactions in canines, so always consult your veterinarian to determine whether it is safe to add these foods to your pet’s diet. This article is for educational and informational purposes and is not a substitute for medical or dietary advice.

Your dream of having a dog who understands words like “sit,” “stay,” “down,” and—crucially— “no” is just a MasterClass Annual Membership away. The only things you’ll need to train up a well-behaved pup are your laptop, a big bag of treats, and our exclusive instructional videos from superstar animal trainer Brandon McMillan.