Bureaucratic Leadership: How Bureaucratic Leadership Works

Bureaucratic leadership is a leadership style that favors rigid structure to enact efficient systems and calculability. This organizational structure lets a company run like a machine because employees know their role and the reporting hierarchy. It is a type of leadership found in many sectors, most often in factories and large corporations.

German Sociologist Max Weber coined the term “bureaucratic leadership” in his 1920 book The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. The bureaucratic leadership structure emerged from the management styles initiated in the Industrial Revolution, and grew into a system in which factories had a clear hierarchy of employee job titles, responsibilities, and direct reports.

Years later, as this model helped accelerate the success of numerous global brands, the famed American sociologist George Ritzer expanded on Weber's definition of bureaucratic leadership, bringing it into the modern era by calling it the "McDonaldization of society," per the title of his 1993 book. Ritzer used McDonald's as an example of a large corporation with a set management structure designed to protect brand identity and allow for expansion.

Bureaucratic systems have several defining features, including:

1. 1. Specialization within each role: In the bureaucratic leadership style, each employee has a specific role that they fulfill, and as such, specialization can lead to overall efficiency with various employees all working together to achieve the desired outcome.
2. 2. Clear decision-making hierarchies: Employees understand who they report to and how decisions are made.
3. 3. Transactional relationships: Employees work a job where what is needed to accomplish a task may rely on a service from another employee. This can make office relationships more transactional than personal and sets clear boundaries between worker responsibilities.
4. 4. Reliance on rules: This form of leadership relies heavily on rules to give employees a set moralistic guidebook, keep them chugging along, and delineate what behavior is rewarded and unacceptable.

The advantages of bureaucratic leadership include reliability for customers and a determined definition of roles. Since bureaucratic leadership prioritizes predictability, customers know what to expect when engaging with the brand’s products or staff. This can aid customer satisfaction. Under bureaucratic leaders, employees understand the definitions of their roles, which makes it easier for workers to succeed since they know expectations.

The disadvantages of bureaucratic leadership can include stifled creativity, slow change, and impersonal working spaces. Bureaucracy is not a kind of laissez-faire leadership; it can create a business environment where creativity and innovation in individual roles can challenge preset guidelines and efficiencies. This also means bureaucratic companies may be slow to change. Team members may find these workspaces to be more impersonal, as they are simply fulfilling set expectations instead of discovering new ways to execute tasks to reform a company.

History has seen various examples of bureaucratic management, where the division of labor and hierarchy of authority are seen as a mode for success. Some famous people who exhibited such leadership qualities include:

1. 1. Winston Churchill (1874–1965): Winston Churchill was the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom during World War II. Churchill was a wartime leader who took a task-oriented approach: Each of his subordinates knew their role, and Churchill streamlined communication to make the British war effort efficient.
2. 2. Steve Easterbrook (1967–): As a former CEO of McDonald’s, Steve Easterbrook is known for helping this fast food chain become one of the world’s most recognizable brands. Easterbrook cemented a hierarchical model within each fast food restaurant and their corporate office to uphold brand identity and enact defined structures for workers.
3. 3. Harold Sydney Geneen (1910–1997): Harold Geneen was the CEO of the International Telephone and Telegraph (ITT) Corporation, an American company creating specialty components for the energy, aerospace, transportation, and industrial markets. Taking a top-down approach, Geneen exemplified bureaucratic management, growing the brand to be a billion-dollar company thanks to its strong systems and delineated employee roles.

Get the MasterClass Annual Membership for exclusive access to video lessons taught by business luminaries, including Chris Voss, Jeff Goodby & Rich Silverstein, Robin Roberts, Sara Blakely, Daniel Pink, Bob Iger, Howard Schultz, Anna Wintour, and more.